The Original Batgirl vs. Alicia Silverstone's Batgirl

Click on one of the choices below to choose who YOU'D do! Not all the choices are going to be between Jessica Alba and Jessica Biel, so keep an open mind!

Sexy or sweet?

Do you prefer a classic babe who likes a man with a great utility belt, or an independent woman who isn't afraid to show off her curves? Decide on your girl and you could be checking out the "Bat Cave" before you know it!

The Original Batgirl

Vitals:

Yvonne Craig played the original Batgirl in the 1960's televison series alongside Adam West.

In the show, Batgirl was none other than Barbera Gorden, commisioner Gorden's daughter and love interest to Batman.

Batgirl was a more wholesome, girl next door sort of superhero in this series, though her spandex suit still raised some interested eyebrows. The character was perfectly designed to fit the cheesiness of the series and her "gee golly" antics fit in perfectly with the innocence of the series.

More a classic beauty than a sultry temptress, Yvonne Craig was the perfect 1960's T.V. heroine.

Alicia Silverstone's Batgirl

Vitals:

Silverstone played Batgirl in the 1997 film "Batman and Robin" alongside George Clooney and Chris O'Donnell. She shows up on the scene as Alfred's neice who helps the dynamic duo defeat the evil Mr. Freeze and that ever-sexy seductress, Poison Ivy.

As is the rule for any female character appearing in a Batman movie, Silverstone wears a curve-hugging black latex suit that makes us wonder if an ass-kicking from her is really such a bad thing after all.

A far cry from the original Batgirl, Alicia brings a fresh load of sex appeal to Gothem City.

Rate This Smackdown:

Average: 5 (1 vote)

At least...

At least their tops are equally poky. Don't put your eye out!

Most Recent Smackdowns

Torrie Wilson vs. Candice Michelle

Who is the better WWE diva and playboy model?

0 Comments

Kristen Bell vs. Hayden Panettiere

It's Heroes season 3 time, and you know what that means! (I hope at least some of you are as excited as I am) Anyways, I don't know if you noticed, but that show does contain quite a few very attractive women... and here are 2 of them! So, who's it gonna be: the electrically charged and shockingly beautiful Elle Bishop (Kristen Bell) or the can't-think-of-a-healing-powers-related-pun-but-still-incredibly-sexy Claire Bennet (Hayden Panettiere)? Choose wisely my friends.

0 Comments

Katie Holmes vs. Maggie Gyllenhaal

The last 2 Batman films featured 2 different ladies in the role of Rachel Dawes (just in case you didn't notice). If you were Christian Bale, who would you be most pumped to have as your leading lady??

0 Comments

Hillary Fisher vs. Christine Dolce

Let's see which popular MySpace model is more popular on this (much cooler) site! Vote now!

1 Comments

Most Popular Smackdowns

Melissa Baker vs. Lauren Michelle Hill

Here we have a smackdown featuring 2 lovely ladies from Maxim's "Ultimate Beaches" article. Representing St. John is the lovely Melissa Baker, and representing South Carolina is the sizzling Lauren Michelle Hill. Which ...um...beach... has what it takes to win your vote??

0 Comments

Natalie Portman - Padme Amidala vs. Carrie Fisher - Princess Leia

Regardles of how you feel about Star Wars, you can appreciate the beauty of these two space heroines. Both come from royalty, love fighting empires and, weirdly enough, are related. It's a choice between mother and daughter, classic favorite vs. captivating newcomer. Even if you're not a sci-fi aficionado, you have a difficult decision to make. May the force be with you.

0 Comments

Jamie Eason vs. Five Bikini Contest Contestants

Last time we pit Jamie Eason against four fitness girls and Jamie still won! Let's if you can decide between FIVE bikini contestants and Jamie!

0 Comments

Theresa Correa vs. Teresa Noreen

Which similarly named American beach babe would YOU rather bang with??

1 Comments

Hillary Fisher vs. Christine Dolce

Let's see which popular MySpace model is more popular on this (much cooler) site! Vote now!

1 Comments

Torrie Wilson vs. Michelle McCool

This smackdown is for real! Which of these 2 lovely pro wrestling divas has got what it takes to win your vote???

0 Comments

Jenna Haze vs. Jenna Jameson

The moral of the story...DON'T NAME YOUR DAUGHTER JENNA.

1 Comments

Christina Scabbia vs. Sharon den Adel

This smackdown features 2 beautiful ladies from the European metal scene. It's the Italians vs. the Dutch as Lacuna Coil's Christina Scabbia takes on Within Temptation's Sharon den Adel. Which one of these heavy metal ladies has the brutal beauty to win your vote?

0 Comments

Rihanna vs. Hayley Williams

Ok, so here we have 2 of the hottest young singers in pop music today (IMHO). In one corner, we have the incredibly sexy (umbrella toting) Rihanna and in the other corner, Paramore's leading lady, the lovely Hayley Williams! Although Miss Williams may be slightly less "mainstream" than Rihanna, they definitey rival each other in hotness...in fact, such a rivalry may very well cause the earth to implode in on itself! A fiery explosion of pop-fueled chaos! Only you can save us all by voting immediately!

0 Comments

Maria Sharapova vs. Anna Kournikova

I know you want them to play doubles, but this is a singles match! You only get to pick ONE.

0 Comments

Most Popular Contestants